Last updated: November 11, 2026 · By the FXPayback Research Desk
Forex brokers make money in four main ways: the spread you pay on every trade, commissions on raw-spread accounts, overnight swap charges, and, for market-maker brokers, client losses on trades they keep in-house. Part of that income is paid to introducing brokers per lot, and that is the money a rebate service returns to you.
Most traders know their broker earns “something” from them. Very few can say how much. And that’s a problem, because the cost you can’t see is the one you never try to cut.
So let’s open the broker’s wallet, line by line, with real numbers.
What are the main ways a forex broker earns money?
- Spread. The gap between the buy and sell price. On a standard account, this is the broker’s main fee. You pay it the moment you open a trade.
- Commission. Raw or ECN-style accounts show tighter spreads but charge a fixed fee per lot, usually per side.
- Swap (rollover). Hold a position past the daily cut-off and you pay or receive interest. Brokers add a markup to the underlying rate.
- Client losses (B-book). A market maker can take the other side of your trade instead of passing it to the market. When you lose, it earns.
- Smaller fees. Currency conversion on deposits, inactivity fees on dormant accounts, and sometimes withdrawal fees.
Out of that income, many brokers pay a share to introducing brokers (IBs), the partners who refer traders. Keep that in mind, because it comes back later.
How much does a broker earn from one lot?
Here’s the basic maths. On EUR/USD, one standard lot is 100,000 units, and one pip is worth $10. So every pip of spread costs you $10 per lot. The table below uses labeled example costs, so plug in your own broker’s figures.
| Trade (1 standard lot) | Example cost | What the broker earns |
|---|---|---|
| EUR/USD, standard account | 1.0 pip spread | $10 |
| EUR/USD, raw account | 0.1 pip spread + $7 round-turn commission | $8 |
| XAU/USD (100 oz), standard account | 25-cent spread | $25 |
| EUR/USD held 5 nights | Say $6 swap per night | $30 extra (part of it is broker markup) |
Now multiply. A trader doing 10 lots of EUR/USD a day on a 1.0-pip spread pays $100 a day, roughly $2,000 over 20 trading days. That’s a car payment, every month, before a single trade has gone your way. For more on overnight charges, see our guide on how to calculate forex swap fees.
What is the difference between A-book and B-book brokers?
This is the part brokers rarely put on the homepage.
A-book (STP/ECN)
The broker passes your order to a liquidity provider, such as a bank or a larger dealer. It earns the spread markup and commission. Your profit or loss doesn’t change its income, so it actually prefers you to stay alive and keep trading.
B-book (market maker)
The broker takes the other side internally. It still earns the spread, but it also keeps the net losses of clients it doesn’t hedge. Most brokers run a mix of both, often moving consistently profitable traders to the A-book.
Why does B-booking pay? Because most retail traders lose. When the European Securities and Markets Authority restricted CFDs in 2018, it said national regulators found that 74–89% of retail accounts typically lose money, with average losses of €1,600 to €29,000 per client. The same measures capped leverage at 30:1 on major pairs and 20:1 on gold, and added negative balance protection.
The scale is real. Plus500, a listed CFD market maker, reported 2025 revenue of $792.4 million from 242,440 active customers, an average revenue per user of $3,268. That’s what the average active client paid that broker in a year, in spreads, financing and trading outcomes combined.
A B-book isn’t automatically a scam. It’s legal and regulated in most places. But it means you should care where your broker is licensed and how it handles execution.
Why do brokers pay introducing brokers, and where do rebates come from?
Brokers spend heavily to win new clients. Instead of paying only for ads, many pay IBs a fixed amount per lot their referred clients trade. That payment comes out of the broker’s own spread and commission income. It isn’t an extra charge added to your trades.
A rebate service is simply an IB that hands most of that per-lot payment back to the trader. You trade exactly as before, and part of what the broker earned from you is returned. Our plain-English rebate guide walks through it step by step. If you’re weighing a rebate against a cheaper account type, this comparison of cashback vs lower spread accounts runs the numbers both ways.
How much of your broker’s cut can you get back?
Let’s run a realistic month. You trade an Exness Standard account: 50 lots of forex and 20 lots of gold.
| Forex (50 lots) | Gold (20 lots) | Total | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Spread paid (example: 1.0 pip / 25 cents) | $500 | $500 | $1,000 |
| FXPayback rebate (at the time of writing) | $2–3/lot = $100–150 | $5–7/lot = $100–140 | $200–290 |
| Net cost after cashback | $350–400 | $360–400 | $710–800 |
That’s $200–290 back in one month, or about $2,400–3,480 a year at the same pace, and it’s paid on losing trades too. Current rates are listed on the Exness cashback page. Want to see how Exness account types compare once cashback is included? Read Exness Standard vs Raw Spread with cashback.
FXPayback has been paying traders since 2020, returns up to 90% of the IB commission, and lets you withdraw from just $1. You can check the real payout proofs before you sign up.
Start getting back part of what your broker earns at FXPayback.com
How can you work out what your broker earns from you?
- Export your statement for the last full month from MT4, MT5 or your broker’s portal.
- Add up the lots traded, split by instrument (forex, gold, indices).
- Multiply by the average spread in dollars per lot. Use the broker’s published typical spread, or note it at your usual trading times.
- Add commissions and swaps, which are listed line by line on the statement.
- Compare the total with your net profit. If costs are bigger than your profit, cost is your biggest problem, not your strategy.
- Work out what a rebate would return using lots × rate per lot.
One honest caution: a rebate lowers costs, but it can’t turn a losing strategy into a winning one. Never trade extra lots just to earn more cashback. That’s the fastest way to hand the B-book exactly what it wants.
Frequently Asked Questions
Do forex brokers want you to lose?
It depends on the model. A pure A-book broker earns the same whether you win or lose and prefers you keep trading. A market maker that keeps your trades in-house earns more when clients lose. Many brokers use a mix, so regulation and execution quality matter.
Is a zero-commission account really free?
No. Zero-commission accounts price the fee into a wider spread. You still pay on every trade. Compare the total cost per lot, spread plus commission, rather than the headline.
Does using a rebate service make my spreads wider?
A rebate is paid from the broker’s IB share, not added to your trade. Your account type decides your spread. To check, compare the published specs of the same account type, and look at your own fills.
How much can I get back with FXPayback?
It depends on broker, account type and volume. At the time of writing, an Exness Standard account pays $2–3 per forex lot and up to $5–7 per gold lot through FXPayback, on winning and losing trades, with a $1 minimum withdrawal.
Risk disclaimer: Trading forex, gold and CFDs involves significant risk and you can lose more than your deposit. Most retail CFD accounts lose money. This article is for information only and is not financial advice.
