Last updated: November 21, 2026 · By the FXPayback Research Desk
An ECN-style broker passes your orders to outside liquidity providers and charges a raw spread plus commission, while a market maker takes the other side itself and earns from a wider spread. Neither is automatically cheaper. On busy majors, raw accounts usually win once spreads average above about 0.8 pips.
Ask ten traders which broker type is better and you’ll get ten loud answers. “Market makers trade against you.” “ECN is the only honest model.” The truth is less dramatic and more useful: what matters is how much each lot costs you, how your orders get filled, and how much of that cost you get back. Let’s work through it with real numbers.
What is the difference between an ECN and a market maker broker?
The global FX market is huge. According to the BIS Triennial Survey, average turnover hit $9.6 trillion a day in April 2025. Retail traders never touch that market directly. Your broker sits between you and it, and how it handles your order is the real difference.
- Market maker (dealing desk, “B-book”): the broker quotes its own prices and takes the opposite side of your trade. It earns from the spread and, when clients lose, from those losses. Australia’s regulator reminds CFD traders that you are dealing directly with the provider, not on an exchange.
- ECN / STP (no dealing desk, “A-book”): the broker routes your order to banks and other liquidity providers. It earns mainly from a commission and a small markup, so it makes money when you trade, not when you lose.
- Hybrid: most large retail brokers do both. They pass some flow to the market and keep the rest in-house, often based on account size and trading style.
One catch: marketing labels prove nothing. “ECN account” is a product name, not a legal status. IC Markets, for example, describes its raw pricing as aggregated from up to 25 institutional sources rather than using the ECN label at all.
Does a market maker really trade against you?
Yes, in the accounting sense. If the broker keeps your trade on its book, your loss is its gain. That’s a real conflict of interest, and it’s why execution quality matters so much.
But here’s the uncomfortable part. A market maker doesn’t need to cheat to profit. When ESMA restricted CFDs in Europe, it found that 74–89% of retail CFD accounts typically lose money. High leverage and trading costs do most of the damage. So the bigger question for your account isn’t “who is on the other side?” It’s “what am I paying on every lot, and are my fills fair?”
Signs of poor execution are the same on any model: frequent requotes, slippage that only ever goes against you, and spreads that jump far wider than the market during news. Our guide on how slippage works and how to reduce it shows how to test this yourself.
Which account type costs less per lot?
Let’s use IC Markets’ published figures, because they show both models side by side. At the time of writing, its Standard account has no commission and spreads from 0.8 pips. Its Raw Spread account charges $3.50 per lot per side ($7 round turn), and the broker states an average EUR/USD spread of 0.1 pips.
On EUR/USD, one pip on a standard lot is worth $10. So the round-turn cost of one lot looks like this:
| Account | Spread cost | Commission | Total per lot | 100 lots a month |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Raw (0.1 pip average) | $1 | $7 | $8 | $800 |
| Standard at 0.8 pips (best case) | $8 | $0 | $8 | $800 |
| Standard at 1.0 pip (example) | $10 | $0 | $10 | $1,000 |
| Standard at 1.2 pips (example) | $12 | $0 | $12 | $1,200 |
Notice the break-even. The Standard account only matches Raw when its spread sits at its 0.8-pip minimum. Every tenth of a pip above that costs you $1 per lot more. If you trade EUR/USD during liquid hours, a raw account usually wins. If you trade exotic pairs, or only a few lots a month, the gap shrinks and simplicity may matter more. We break down where all that money goes in how forex brokers make money.
How does cashback change the ECN vs market maker maths?
This is where most comparisons stop too early. Rebates are usually higher on spread-based accounts, because the broker earns more per lot there. You can see it on FXPayback’s IC Markets page: at the time of writing, gold pays up to $3.60 per lot on Standard but up to $1.80 on Raw Spread.
Let’s run a forex example. Say your rebate is $3 per lot on Standard and $1.50 on Raw (illustrative figures, check the broker page for live rates). You trade 100 lots of EUR/USD a month.
- Standard at 1.0 pip: $1,000 cost minus $300 cashback = $700 net
- Raw at 0.1 pip + $7: $800 cost minus $150 cashback = $650 net
- Standard at 1.2 pips: $1,200 minus $300 = $900 net
Cashback narrows the gap a lot. At 1.0 pip, the difference between the two accounts drops from $200 to $50 a month. On Exness, the confirmed Standard rebate is $2–3 per lot on forex and up to $5–7 on gold at the time of writing (see Exness cashback), which is why some gold traders end up cheaper on a Standard account. We ran that exact comparison in Exness Standard vs Raw Spread with cashback.
FXPayback returns up to 90% of the IB commission on every lot, win or lose. We’ve been paying traders since 2020, withdrawals start at $1, and our payout proofs are public.
Start getting cashback on every lot you trade at FXPayback.com
How can you check which model your broker really uses?
- Read the order execution policy. Search it for “principal”, “counterparty” or “riskless principal”. If the broker acts as principal, it can hold your trades in-house.
- Check the regulator register. Confirm the exact legal entity your account sits under and what licence it holds. Offshore and top-tier entities of the same brand can work differently.
- Look at the pricing. A commission plus near-zero spreads usually signals external pricing. Fixed or wide spreads with no commission are typical of in-house dealing.
- Log your fills for a month. Record requested price versus filled price. Fair execution shows slippage in both directions, not just against you.
- Watch news spreads. Every broker widens during NFP or CPI. Extreme widening only on your platform is a red flag.
Which broker type should you choose?
- Scalpers and high-volume traders: raw or ECN-style accounts usually cost less per lot. Add cashback and the savings grow with volume.
- Beginners trading small size: a Standard account keeps costs simple. With a rebate, the cost gap to Raw is often small.
- Gold traders: compare net cost after cashback, since gold rebates on spread accounts can be generous.
- Swap-free traders: check that the Islamic option exists on the account type you pick. XM, for example, offers an Islamic option on all its account types.
Before you switch accounts, plug your own volume into the rebate calculator. Your numbers beat any rule of thumb.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is an ECN broker safer than a market maker?
Not by itself. Safety depends on regulation, client fund segregation and the legal entity you sign up with. A well-regulated market maker can be safer than a loosely regulated “ECN” brand.
Can I tell a broker’s model from its spreads alone?
Only partly. Commission plus raw spreads suggests external pricing, but many brokers run hybrid books. The order execution policy is the most reliable document to check.
Do market makers allow scalping?
Many do, but some restrict very short trades in their terms. Read the client agreement before you scalp, because breaking those rules can lead to cancelled profits.
Does FXPayback cashback work on both ECN and Standard accounts?
Yes, on most partner brokers. Rates differ by account type, so check the broker’s FXPayback page. Rebates are paid on every lot, win or lose, and you can withdraw from $1.
Risk disclaimer: Trading forex, gold and CFDs involves significant risk and you can lose more than your deposit. This article is for information only and is not financial advice.
